Public Liability vs Professional Indemnity vs Contractors All Risk
What’s the Difference?

CALL FOR EXPERT ADVICE
GET A QUOTE NOW

A clear guide to the three main types of construction insurance - what they cover, when you need them, and how they protect your business.

CALL FOR EXPERT ADVICE
GET A QUOTE NOW

We compare quotes from leading UK construction insurers

THREE CORE COVERS - BUT VERY DIFFERENT PURPOSES

  • PUBLIC LIABILITY (PL)

  • PROFESSIONAL INDEMNITY (PI)

  • CONTRACTORS ALL RISK (CAR)

  • RISK MANAGEMENT

What’s the Difference Between PL, PI and CAR Insurance?

Public Liability, Professional Indemnity and Contractors All Risk insurance each protect construction businesses in different ways. Knowing which one you need - and when - is essential for compliance, contract requirements and financial protection.

This guide explains the differences in simple terms, helping contractors, trades, developers and consultants choose the right combination of cover.

Public Liability Insurance - What Does It Cover?

Protection if your work causes injury or property damage to others.


  • Injury to members of the public
  • Accidental damage to a client’s property
  • Damage caused by subcontractors (depending on policy)
  • Trip, slip or fall claims on-site
  • Use of heat tools, working at height & general hazards
  • Legal defence & compensation costs

Professional Indemnity Insurance - What Does It Cover?


  • Incorrect design, plans or specifications
  • Professional advice or consultancy errors
  • Negligence causing financial loss
  • Surveying, engineering or architectural mistakes
  • Legal defence costs & settlements

Contractors All Risk (CAR) - What Does It Cover?


  • Damage to works-in-progress
  • Damage to materials on-site
  • Damage to temporary buildings, fencing & site huts
  • Owned & hired-in plant, tools & machinery
  • Theft, fire, flood, storm & accidental damage
  • Continuing hire charges (for hired-in plant)

PL vs PI vs CAR - Simple Comparison


  • PL = covers injury or property damage to others
  • PI = covers professional mistakes causing financial loss
  • CAR = covers building works, materials & plant
  • Many contractors require all three types of cover
  • Most construction contracts and main contractors require PI & CAR for higher-risk work

“We didn’t know the difference between PI, PL and CAR - Insure24 explained it clearly and made sure we had the right cover for each project.”

Michael R., Building Contractor

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

+-

Do I need all three types of insurance?

Most contractors benefit from having PL, PI and CAR together - they protect completely different risks and complement each other.

+-

Is Professional Indemnity only for architects and engineers?

No - builders, trades and contractors may need PI if they provide specifications, design input, consultancy or advice.

+-

Does CAR include tools and plant?

Yes - CAR can include owned tools, hired-in plant, materials on-site and works in progress.

+-

Is Public Liability enough for most builders?

Public Liability is essential, but it will not protect you against design errors, financial loss claims or damage to your own work - this is where PI and CAR are needed.

+-

Do main contractors require PI or CAR from subcontractors?

Yes - many principal contractors require evidence of PI and CAR for subcontractors working on structural, design-related or high-value projects.

Related Blogs

Latent Defects Insurance: Structural Defect Coverage

Latent defects insurance represents a critical component of risk management in the construction and property development sectors. This specialized form of coverage protects property owners, developers…

Defects Liability Insurance: Post-Completion Protection

In the construction industry, the completion of a project doesn't mark the end of responsibility. Defects can emerge months or even years after handover, leaving contractors, developers, and proper…

Best Construction Insurance Providers UK 2025

By Insure 24

Best Construction Insurance Providers UK 2025

The construction industry in the UK faces unique risks daily, from equipment damage and public liability claims to professional indemnity issues and project delays. Choosing the right insurance provider can …

Construction Insurance Renewal: 12-Point Checklist

Renewing your construction insurance is one of the most critical tasks you'll undertake as a business owner in the building trade. Whether you're a general contractor, specialist tradesperson, or constr…

Tool Theft on Construction Sites: Insurance Protection

Tool theft on construction sites represents one of the most persistent and costly challenges facing the UK construction industry. With millions of pounds worth of equipment stolen annually, construc…

Scaffolding Insurance: Temporary Works Coverage

Scaffolding contractors face unique risks every day. From working at height to managing expensive equipment and navigating complex liability issues, the scaffolding industry demands specialized insurance p…

Demolition Insurance: High-Risk Work Protection

Demolition work represents one of the most hazardous activities in the construction industry. From bringing down multi-storey buildings to dismantling industrial structures, demolition contractors face uni…

Handyman Insurance: Multi-Trade Coverage Explained

Published on 4 November 2025 | Reading time: 12 minutes

Running a handyman business means juggling multiple trades, unpredictable situations, and significant liability risks. Whether …

Bricklayer Insurance: Masonry & Site Liability

By Insure 24

Bricklayer Insurance: Masonry & Site Liability

Bricklaying is a skilled trade that involves significant risks—from working at heights and handling heavy materials to potential damage claims and workplace injuries. Whether you're a self-employed …

Groundworker Insurance: Excavation & Ground Risks

Groundworkers face some of the most demanding and hazardous conditions on any construction site. From excavating foundations to managing underground utilities, the risks are substantial and multifaceted.…

Carpenter Insurance: Woodwork & Site Risk Protection

Carpentry is a skilled trade that demands precision, expertise, and dedication. Whether you're a self-employed joiner, a small carpentry team, or managing a larger construction outfit, the ris…

Gas Engineer Insurance: Gas Safe & Boiler Installation

Gas engineers and heating technicians face unique risks in their daily work. From boiler installations to emergency repairs, the potential for costly claims is significant. This comprehensive guide …

Construction Insurance Claims: Step-by-Step Process

When accidents, damage, or losses occur on a construction site, knowing how to navigate the insurance claims process can make all the difference. This comprehensive guide walks you through each stage o…