My Account
We compare quotes from leading insurers
Why Medical Device Manufacturers Get Confused by These Three Covers
Product Liability, Professional Indemnity (PI) / Technology Errors & Omissions (E&O), and Product Recall insurance are three separate policies — each designed to respond to different triggers.
In medical device manufacturing, a single incident can involve all three. For example: a design flaw leads to incorrect outputs, customers demand compensation, and you must issue a Field Safety Notice to correct devices in the field.
Understanding what each policy is designed to cover — and what it does not cover — is critical to avoiding uninsured gaps.
1️⃣ Product Liability Insurance
Product Liability insurance is designed to cover third-party injury or property damage caused by your product.
What It Covers
- Bodily injury claims linked to device use
- Property damage caused by device malfunction
- Legal defence costs
- Settlements and damages (subject to limits)
What It Does NOT Cover
- The cost to recall or replace your own product
- Pure financial loss where no injury occurred
- Design service disputes (unless injury/property damage)
2️⃣ Professional Indemnity (PI) / Technology E&O
PI / Tech E&O is designed to cover financial loss claims arising from negligent design, professional advice, software errors or failure to perform as specified.
What It Covers
- Financial loss claims (no injury required)
- Software failure or algorithm disputes
- Contractual performance allegations (subject to wording)
- Design and advisory errors
What It Does NOT Cover
- Physical recall costs
- Property damage (unless endorsed)
- Operational retrieval and logistics
3️⃣ Product Recall / Field Safety Corrective Action Insurance
Recall insurance is designed to pay for the operational costs of correcting or withdrawing defective devices from the market.
What It Covers
- Notification and communication costs
- Retrieval, transport and logistics
- Repair, rework or replacement
- Disposal and destruction
- Crisis management (where included)
What It Does NOT Cover
- Third-party injury damages (Product Liability)
- Pure contractual performance disputes (PI/E&O)
- Cyber ransom payments (Cyber Insurance)
How These Policies Work Together in Real Incidents
A single software-driven device issue could trigger:
- Product Liability — if injury is alleged
- PI / Tech E&O — if customers claim financial loss
- Recall Insurance — to fund field corrective action
- Cyber Insurance — if a security breach was involved
The key is aligning definitions, retroactive dates, territorial scope and contract assumptions so you don’t have grey areas between policies.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
+-
Can one policy cover everything?
No. These policies are designed for different triggers. Combining them correctly avoids gaps.
+-
Does Product Liability cover recall costs?
No. Product Liability covers third-party injury/property damage claims, not the cost of recalling or replacing your own devices.
+-
When is PI more important than Product Liability?
When your exposure is primarily financial loss from design or software performance rather than bodily injury.
+-
Do software-enabled devices require all three?
In most cases, yes — particularly if devices are connected, distributed widely, or contractually performance-based.
+-
Can Insure24 align these policies together?
Yes. We structure coordinated insurance programmes for medical device manufacturers to reduce coverage gaps and improve claims clarity.