New Build Warranty vs Property Developer Insurance: Understanding the Key Differences

  • Home
  • Blog
  • New Build Warranty vs Property Developer Insurance: Understanding the Key Differences

New Build Warranty vs Property Developer Insurance: Understanding the Key Differences

GET A QUOTE NOW
GET A QUOTE NOW

New Build Warranty vs Property Developer Insurance: Understanding the Key Differences

When it comes to protecting new build properties and the developers who create them, two distinct types of coverage often cause confusion: New Build Warranty and Property Developer Insurance. While both play crucial roles in the construction and property development sector, they serve very different purposes and protect different parties. Understanding these differences is essential for property developers, builders, and new home buyers alike.

What is New Build Warranty?

New Build Warranty, also known as structural warranty or NHBC warranty (when provided by the National House Building Council), is a form of insurance that protects new home buyers against structural defects and other issues that may arise after purchase. This warranty is typically arranged by the developer or builder but benefits the homeowner.

Key Features of New Build Warranty:

Coverage Period

Usually lasts 10 years from completion, with different levels of cover at different stages:

  • Years 1-2: Builder's liability for defects
  • Years 3-10: Insurance cover for major structural defects

What's Covered

  • Major structural defects affecting the stability of the property
  • Damage caused by subsidence, heave, or landslip
  • Double glazing seal failure
  • Central heating and hot water system defects (limited period)
  • Incomplete work if the builder becomes insolvent

Who Benefits: The homeowner and subsequent owners during the warranty period

Cost: Typically paid by the developer/builder as part of the development costs

What is Property Developer Insurance?

Property Developer Insurance is a comprehensive business insurance package designed to protect property developers and construction companies during the development process. This insurance protects the developer's business interests, assets, and liabilities throughout the construction phase and beyond.

Key Components of Property Developer Insurance:

Contract Works Insurance

  • Covers the construction project against damage from fire, theft, vandalism, and weather
  • Protects materials, plant, and equipment on site
  • Includes temporary buildings and site huts

Public Liability Insurance

  • Covers claims from third parties injured on or near the construction site
  • Protects against property damage caused to neighboring properties
  • Essential for planning permission and contractor requirements

Employers' Liability Insurance

  • Mandatory coverage for any business with employees
  • Covers claims from workers injured during construction
  • Includes subcontractors in many cases

Professional Indemnity Insurance

  • Covers design errors and professional negligence claims
  • Protects against financial losses caused by professional mistakes
  • Includes defense costs for legal proceedings

Plant and Equipment Insurance

  • Covers construction machinery, tools, and equipment
  • Includes theft, accidental damage, and breakdown cover
  • Can cover hired-in plant and equipment

Key Differences Between New Build Warranty and Property Developer Insurance

1. Primary Beneficiary

  • New Build Warranty: Protects the homeowner/buyer
  • Property Developer Insurance: Protects the developer/builder's business

2. Coverage Period

  • New Build Warranty: Long-term protection (typically 10 years post-completion)
  • Property Developer Insurance: Active during development phase and immediate post-completion period

3. Types of Risks Covered

  • New Build Warranty: Structural defects, incomplete work, specific building system failures
  • Property Developer Insurance: Construction risks, business liabilities, professional errors, equipment damage

4. When Coverage Applies

  • New Build Warranty: After property completion and handover
  • Property Developer Insurance: During construction and development phases

5. Legal Requirements

  • New Build Warranty: Often required by mortgage lenders for new builds
  • Property Developer Insurance: Various components legally required (e.g., employers' liability)

Why Both Types of Insurance Are Important

For Property Developers:

Risk Management: Property Developer Insurance provides comprehensive protection during the high-risk construction phase, while New Build Warranty helps maintain reputation and customer confidence.

Legal Compliance: Many components of Property Developer Insurance are legally required, and New Build Warranty is often demanded by mortgage lenders.

Business Continuity: Property Developer Insurance protects against potentially business-ending claims during construction, while New Build Warranty reduces post-completion liability exposure.

Competitive Advantage: Offering comprehensive New Build Warranty can differentiate developers in a competitive market.

For Homebuyers:

Peace of Mind: New Build Warranty provides long-term protection against expensive structural problems.

Mortgage Requirements: Most lenders require New Build Warranty for mortgage approval on new builds.

Resale Value: Properties with transferable warranties often maintain better resale values.

Financial Protection: Coverage against incomplete work if the builder becomes insolvent.

Common Misconceptions

"New Build Warranty Covers Everything"

New Build Warranty has specific exclusions and limitations. It typically doesn't cover:

  • Normal wear and tear
  • Damage caused by homeowner negligence
  • Non-structural defects after the initial period
  • Cosmetic issues

"Property Developer Insurance Isn't Needed for Small Projects"

Even small developments face significant risks. A single accident or professional error claim could exceed the value of the entire project.

"One Policy Covers Both Needs"

While some insurers offer combined packages, New Build Warranty and Property Developer Insurance serve different purposes and typically require separate arrangements.

Choosing the Right Coverage

For Property Developers:

Assess Project Scale: Larger developments require more comprehensive coverage and higher policy limits.

Consider Location Risks: Urban sites may have higher public liability risks, while rural sites might face different challenges.

Evaluate Subcontractor Arrangements: Ensure coverage extends to subcontractor activities and potential gaps in their insurance.

Plan for Post-Completion: Consider run-off cover for professional indemnity and extended coverage periods.

For Homebuyers:

Verify Warranty Provider: Ensure the warranty is provided by a reputable, financially stable organization.

Understand Coverage Levels: Know what's covered in each year of the warranty period.

Check Transferability: Ensure the warranty can be transferred to future owners.

Review Exclusions: Understand what isn't covered to avoid disappointment later.

The Claims Process

New Build Warranty Claims:

  1. Report defects to the builder first (usually years 1-2)
  2. If unresolved, contact the warranty provider
  3. Independent inspection arranged
  4. Approved repairs carried out or compensation paid

Property Developer Insurance Claims:

  1. Immediate notification to insurers
  2. Risk assessment and damage limitation
  3. Investigation and liability determination
  4. Settlement or legal defense as appropriate

Cost Considerations

New Build Warranty Costs:

  • Typically 0.1% to 0.5% of build cost
  • One-time premium paid by developer
  • Cost varies by property type, location, and warranty provider

Property Developer Insurance Costs:

  • Usually 0.5% to 2% of project value annually
  • Varies significantly based on project size, location, and risk profile
  • Multiple policy components with different premium calculations

Future Trends and Considerations

Regulatory Changes:

  • Building safety regulations continue to evolve post-Grenfell
  • Enhanced warranty requirements for certain building types
  • Increased focus on fire safety and cladding issues

Technology Integration:

  • Digital monitoring systems affecting warranty terms
  • Smart home technology creating new coverage considerations
  • Drone and AI technology changing risk assessment

Environmental Factors:

  • Climate change affecting structural warranty risks
  • Sustainable building methods requiring specialized coverage
  • Flood and weather-related claims increasing

Conclusion

New Build Warranty and Property Developer Insurance serve complementary but distinct roles in the property development ecosystem. While New Build Warranty provides long-term peace of mind for homeowners, Property Developer Insurance protects the business interests of developers during the critical construction phase.

Understanding these differences is crucial for making informed decisions about coverage levels, policy selection, and risk management strategies. Property developers should view both types of insurance as essential investments in their business success and reputation, while homebuyers should ensure they understand the protection offered by New Build Warranty before making their purchase.

The key to success lies in working with experienced insurance professionals who understand the unique challenges of property development and can tailor coverage to meet specific project needs. Whether you're a developer planning your next project or a buyer considering a new build property, proper insurance coverage is an investment in long-term security and success.

By recognizing that New Build Warranty and Property Developer Insurance work together rather than compete, all parties in the property development process can better protect their interests and create successful outcomes for everyone involved.